Tips by Dr. Lori

McCoy Pottery

by Dr. Lori Verderame
McCoy Pottery

McCoy Pottery Company - Its History

In 1910, Nelson McCoy established the Nelson McCoy Sanitary Stoneware Co. in Roseville, OH. This area of Ohio provided a good source for natural clay and the McCoy firm used this clay to manufacture decorative stoneware. Predominantly producing earthenware pieces for kitchen use, the company expanded in 1925 modernizing its production facilities. Decorative pieces were produced in addition to their traditional kitchen items. 

By the mid 1920, McCoy hired designers to sculpt and decorate the pottery. During the Depression, McCoy condensed resources by working with other pottery firms in the American Clay Products organization. By 1933, the company was renamed, the Nelson McCoy Pottery Company and many new designs were introduced. 

McCoy pottery markIn addition to the firm's famous figural cookie jars, McCoy planters, vases, and other utilitarian pottery remain popular with collectors. These pieces regularly command high values.

McCoy Cookie Jars

From the 1940s to the 1960s, McCoy was best known for its production of cookie jars. The original "Mammy" also known as the Aunt Jemima type cookie jar is arguably the most popular with McCoy cookie jar collectors. McCoy made cookie jars from about 1939 until production ceased in 1987. The first McCoy cookie jar produced is also one of the most valuable cookie jars in the secondary market today, called the "Mammy" cookie jar which can be valued into the several hundreds of dollars.

By the 1960s, McCoy was McCoy cookie jarexperiencing numerous financial difficulties as the firm was unable to compete on the international import market. The McCoy firm was sold to The Mount Clemens Pottery Company in 1967 and then to the Lancaster Colony Corporation in 1974. In 1990, production stopped and the McCoy company ceased business.

Request an online appraisal of your McCoy pottery piece from Dr. Lori.

Schedule a Dr. Lori Event

Dr. Lori events
Dr. Lori presents her popular Antiques Appraisal Comedy Show around the world at 150 shows a year entertaining audiences. Ask us how to book an event for you.

Dr. Lori's Blog

Dr. Lori reveals insider information and tips about the world of antiques. Subscribe here »
3 Ways to Find Valuable Antiques

3 Ways to Find Valuable Antiques

Want to know how to spot that valuable thrift store find? Don't know what to look for when cleaning out Grandma's attic or when you are downsizing? It's a common question and Dr. Lori provides secrets to spot those prints, posters, silver and ceramics that are valuable. Don't rely only on marks or signatures. They could fool you. You must read this article so you aren't throwing away a valuable or walking past it at a thrift store.

Read More »